Street Voices
Street Voices / The story
Street Voices, NationalStories from our community

Black Students vs The School System: A Personal Reflection

Black Students vs The School System: A Personal Reflection

By Tisania Smith

In a society where success is most often measured by the prestige of a post-secondary degree, one could believe that everyone has a fair shot in this achievement, with the only barrier being a lack of determination and hard work. Unfortunately for Black students, this isn’t quite the case. 

Throughout the years, the bias placed on Black students and our success levels is very evident. This can happen blatantly, like from my experience in the way a teacher would speak to me and my Black friends versus the way they spoke to my white friends, but it also happens systemically.

A friend, who is a physiotherapy student at Brock University (and has chosen to be identified as “AJ”), revealed the amount of discouragement and doubt he faced on his path to achieve his university acceptance letter. When faced with lower grades than anticipated in a particular class, the guidance counselor urged a transition into applied classes, or to consider a completely different pathway in post secondary. 

Academic vs applied classes was supposed to provide options to the various learning styles students may have, with academic focusing on theoretical learning while applied emphasizing hand-on learning. Instead, it has created barriers that have affected racialized and lower-income students.  

AJ recalls the meetings he had with his guidance counselor in which although being enrolled in academic classes, was urged to transition into applied. 

“She was shocked when I came back and told her I had gotten accepted by Brock,” he said. “She gave a, ‘What? How?’ kind of response, after trying to talk me out of applying in the first place.”

Lisa St. Louis, a Political Science student at McMaster University with an ongoing epileptic medical condition, believed that the perception of her potential by her high school was measured by her intersectional identity, rather than her ability to perform well academically. Similar to AJ, her teachers would push her towards college rather than universities, and even suggested she take a year off following graduation. 

She believed it had not only to do with her identity as a Black woman, but also with the misunderstanding regarding her epilepsy and lack of support provided. As a result of the stigma placed on her as a student, she refrained from accepting extra help, in fear of judgement from faculty. 

According to data from the Toronto District School Board (which is the only public school district in Ontario that collects data on their students regarding race, gender, etc), 49% of Black students in high school were enrolled in academic classes in 2011. Compare this to the 77% of white students who were enrolled in the same classes, and you see a distinct difference. Why are Black students often overlooked and underestimated within walls that are supposed to set students up for success? 

Socioeconomic variables have played a significant role in the judgement placed on Black students, as it lowers expected level of achievement. It was reported that Black youth from the ages of 9-17 in 2006 lived with at least one parent with a university degree. As research develops, it has been revealed that a parent's education is one of the most impactful determinants of children’s outcomes in the education system. 

St. Louis continued to reflect on the root of her experience by addressing her single parent, immigrant household and how that created inaccurate opinions on her ability as a student. Coming from a predominately white school, she received quite a bit of ignorance and stereotyping as a Black woman. Lisa detailed a memory from her high school experience in which posters supporting black history month were torn down within a day due to other parents feeling “offended” by the content. 

“Educational institutions are complicit with discriminatory actions,” St. Louis says. 

As much as our experiences are valid and real to us, it is still not clear for everyone. We need more investments into studies that will evidently showcase what we are going through. 

Currently, it is difficult to find data analytics regarding the experiences of racialized students within Canadian schools. Despite their PR attempts from schools and school boards to vocalize their support toward an inclusive and welcoming environment, it is clear there has not been a real attempt to make the changes necessary. This also carries over to post secondary, as 63 of the 76 Canadian universities do not have data regarding their racial demographics due to the lack of inquiry amongst their students. 

That needs to change. We need to apply pressure to these institutions by investing more into analytics that can support our experiences. It is unfortunate that human dignity is clearly not a priority for them and that we have to resort to translating our experiences into a language that they can understand, but we must do what is necessary to create systemic change. That is the way we can ensure that Black students can finally reach their full potential without the barriers that we had to face

Keep discovering.More from Street Voices