Two new University of Toronto studies reveal that Black students in the Toronto District School Board (TDSB) continue to face systemic barriers, excessive discipline, and harmful stereotypes that impact their education and well-being.
PhD student Olivia Bernard interviewed Black female students in a Black Creek-area high school between 2021 and 2022. Her research found that stereotypes about Black girls often translated into disproportionate discipline from teachers. In one disturbing example, a teacher told a group of Black girls that if there was a bucket of fried chicken, they would have been running to class.
Meanwhile, U of T professor Ahmed Ilmi conducted a study with 32 Somali youth in Rexdale, hearing repeated stories of Islamophobia and anti-Black racism. Students shared how teachers labeled them “terrorists” for wearing a hijab, ignored them in class, or punished them for speaking up in ways that non-Black students were praised for. Ilmi described these experiences as “dehumanizing” and said they contribute to systemic exclusion from academic achievement.
Both researchers highlighted how Black students are often denied access to rigorous academic opportunities such as International Baccalaureate programs, and how the lack of Black role models in high-paying careers discourages young people from setting high standards for themselves.
“The classroom is the first place where you learn your place in the world,” Ilmi told the Toronto Star. “When you feel out of place in the classroom, you’re disconnected from the rest of society.”
The studies echo the Ontario Human Rights Commission’s call earlier this year for “bold” action to dismantle anti-Black racism in Ontario schools. Bernard and Ilmi argue that the TDSB must hire more Black teachers, improve anti-bias training, and invest in the Centre of Excellence for Black Student Achievement, which remains under-resourced.
While these findings highlight systemic barriers, Ilmi emphasized that Black students remain determined to pursue their goals: “It wasn’t like they folded their hands and expected that they weren’t doing great things. They had great hopes and aspirations for achieving everything that they were told that they were not.”
Source: Toronto Star, article by Nathan Bawaan
Photo credits: All photos by Katerine Holmes through Pexels.com.
